Tuesday, December 22, 2009

Essay 8 (Phil Lit)

In a home where domestic violence occur like in the poem Pansit, who is to be blamed? Why?

17 comments:

Anonymous said...

Tabios, L.M.
MWF 2:00-3:00

For me it is the father in which to be blamed, he is irresponsible and nothing,every time He got home He always hurt his wife which shows that He is a nobody. Without realizing that his son is watching over them. It has a bad effect on the child.

Torreña,Wella D. MWF 11:00-12:00 said...

For me, the father should be blamed because he used violence to hurt his wife whenever he is angry for no good reason and he didnt mind that his son is watching on them and it has a big effect on the child and is exposed to violence and may be passed that kind of violence when the child will have his own family and will hurt his wife just like his father do

Butad,J.M (MWF 11-12) said...

For me, the father is the one to be blamed because mother is giving only what she can give and pansit is a good viand. Violence start at home and it may imprint it to the mind of the child that may cause a bad effect. Family always a love to each other so that it will build a good relationship.

Anonymous said...

YGOT JOCELYN C.
MWF 2-3
The one that is to blame is the father.If i am the wife,I will not let him hurt me only for the reason that the viand is always pansit.If he really wants another viand,he will make an effort to be able to have another viand or he will cook his own food in order to have peace.

Anonymous said...

bretaña.cm
mwf 2-3

The father is to be blame,he should work hard to afford those luxurious viand if that's what he wants and never hurt me just for that reason.

Anonymous said...

Clam, A.J
MWF 9-10

The father, in proper way, it was the father who works for his family to provide the needs. In the poem the father show how violent he is by treating his wife as a servant. He show his bad attitude infront of his child which is not a good example. The father should be the role model of the family.

Pepito,R said...

Domestic violence can be blame to both father and mother because thr father should give the enough amount inorder for the wife to budget it will for a better food.The father's reaction in the poem is not so acceptable because partially he is the reason why his wife is always cooking pancit yet the mother will also be blamed because she is spending more of her time in gambling rather than making the house chores.

Anonymous said...

Rey, A.
MWF 9-10

The father. The father is the provider of the family. So he is responsible for the needs of his family. And he has no right to hurt the woman in the poem because he give only a budget good for pansit only, so we couldn’t blame the mother.

ruzell said...

Yanson, J.R.
MWF 9-10

The father, As a father, he should be the one to find ways to earn money so that he could gave them a better life and to feed his family well. He has no right to hurt his wife, because his the reason and must be blamed for their situation.

Jumawan, Debra said...

Jumawan, Debra
MWF 9-10

The father is the one to be blame because he always complains in the pancit prepared by his wife. Infact the father is the provider of the family; he has all the responsibility to provide money for better food. Although, it is not wrong in complaining but do it in proper ways not in cruel way.

joevy said...

Coopera, Jovelyn M.
MWF 9-10

Practically speaking, both the mother and the father. Because even the father works to provide the needs of his family, it was the mother who organized the things inside the house.

angel said...

Saldaña, Angelita P.
MWF 9-10

For me, both Mother and Father who is to be blamed because the father is effortless, irresponsible and jobless because of this he can abused or hurt his wife. and the Mother let her husband hurt her.

Aldrin Marc said...

Bahian, Aldrin Marc C.
MWF 2-3

Of course, no one but the father. The viand is not a good reason for a man's ridiculous rage. If you never like the viand anymore, you can find or cook another one you like.

Anonymous said...

De La Torre, Eduard P.
MWF 2-3

For me, the father should be blamed, because the father are responsible for foods or needs of their family.

Anonymous said...

Verula,J T.
MWF-9-10:00
Pansit tells us a typical Filipino family who gets into misunderstanding especially if a member commits a mistake. i could not blame any of the characters in the poem because they all have the responsibility to please each other. It maybe exaggerated how the author wrote the poem but the essence of it is that a family must have to understand each other and knows how to deal in every situation they will encounter to minimize misunderstandings.

Anonymous said...

FOR ME THE FATHER SHOULD BE BLAME BECAUSE HE WILL BE THE WHO USED A VOILENCE TO HURT HIS WIFE. AND THE MOST BAD COMMENT I THAT IN EVERY TIME HE GET ANGRY HE DIDNT MIND THAT HIS SON IS WATCHING,HE DID NOT THINK THAT WHAT THE CAUSE OF HIS DOING A WRONG THINGS.

Anonymous said...

apple jane
MWF 9-10

For me maam! it is the father in which to be blamed.He is irresponsible because he used or he do a bad things that the wife get hurt.And he never raealize the good for his son he didnt mind that his son is watching.

A Portrait of the Artist as Filipino by Nick Joaquin

  A Portrait of the Artist as Filipino -Nick Joaquin (An Elegy in Three Scenes)   How but in custom and in ceremony Are innocence ...