Tuesday, December 22, 2009

Essay 7( Phil Lit)

Was the love shared by the persona and his lady love in the poem "Walang Hanggan" pure and chaste? Why?

12 comments:

Anonymous said...

YGOT JOCELYN C.
MWF 2-3

For me,the persona shared love with the lady.You can just state it by just merely looking of the title.Walang Hanggan means forever even death do us part,it is really forever even life after death.

Anonymous said...

bretaña,cm
mwf 2-3

The persona shared love to the lady whom he loves and he dedicates his life ,his whole life to the maiden whom he really love.

Pepito,R said...

No,because even in thier emagination they had already committed sin against the purity of thier love.

Jumawan, Debra said...

Jumawan, Debra
MWF 9-10

The persona shared in this poem was only imagination and lust of the
boy.

ruzell said...

Yanson, J.R.
MWF 9-10

NO, its not pure, because he only loves the girl in his imagination and he thinks lustful things towards both of them and that is sin.

joevy said...

Coopera,Jovelyn M.
MWF 9-10

For me it is not love. It is an imagination of the guy who wants to be love by the girl. That’s why he is imagining that the girl and he love each other.

Kibos, Ma. Vanessa G. said...

The persona shared in this poem was only an imagination because it is only the lustfulness shared between two of them.

angel said...

Saldaña, Angelita P.
MWF 9-10

No, it is not pure because even if the relationship is far or near it have still a lustful imagination that may cause sin against the purity of their love.

Anonymous said...

Rey, A.
MWF 9-10

yes, he loves the lady in the poem. Even they are apart they can still love one-another if they have trust among themselves. Imagining the lady is not a lust but it is a way to restore his loneliness.

Anonymous said...

Rey, A.
MWF 9-10

yes, he loves the lady in the poem. Even they are apart they can still love one-another if they have trust among themselves. Imagining the lady is not a lust but it is a way to forget his loneliness.

Anonymous said...

Verula,J T.
MWF-9-10:00
As i read the poem it makes me think How sad is the persona for having such situation. it only depend on how we really go about the poem situation we cannot always say that it is bad to do such imaginations because it is really different if your afar from your beloved. even if if we talk about purity we can still it is because he is able to maintain his feeling. having such imagination is natural,a mechanism to remember,it maybe not stated in the poem but the truth behind a true to life situation will agree that the persona was having a pure love.

Anonymous said...

Apple Jane
MWF 9-10

The persona love to the lady whom he loves and he dedicated his life.His life to the maiden whom really love.

A Portrait of the Artist as Filipino by Nick Joaquin

  A Portrait of the Artist as Filipino -Nick Joaquin (An Elegy in Three Scenes)   How but in custom and in ceremony Are innocence ...